My view the Black Pack would win. Despite what anybody tells you, size does matter. Colin and Brady are basically kids that means the more vicious members of the Uley Pack are Jarrett & Sam, Paul. The Black Pack on the other hand is led by Jacob who by Sam's own admission is the best fighter. Jacob also works best with Quill and Embry both of whom eventually joined his pack. When angry Jacob has always seemed more aggressive than Sam. Tell me your view.