Twilight Saga Wiki
Register
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
  +
   
   
Line 12: Line 13:
   
 
[[User:BellaOrwell|BellaOrwell]] 07:08, 24 November 2008 (UTC)
 
[[User:BellaOrwell|BellaOrwell]] 07:08, 24 November 2008 (UTC)
  +
  +
   
   
Line 20: Line 23:
   
 
Twilight_lover
 
Twilight_lover
  +
   
   
Line 27: Line 31:
   
 
[[User:The last horcrux|The last horcrux]] 01:21, 25 November 2008 (UTC)
 
[[User:The last horcrux|The last horcrux]] 01:21, 25 November 2008 (UTC)
----
 
   
  +
<nowiki> </nowiki>
== Industry Reviews ==
 
   
  +
I read the series over the summer and loved them. I am a guy which alot find strange but the way i see it is that gender doesnt matter what you read, and i am not gay which i have been teased about ready this book, anyways I loved the books and i obsessed over the movie all summer and I had posters and picture on msn and myspace but sadly I hated the movie. The effects stunk alot, at the end of the movie I seriously thought is that it? I think the fight scene was the only exciting part and then of course edward was bleeding and if i recall so wwas james. Now i thought vampires couldnt bleed. Another thing is when alice ripes jame's head off it looks like she's slapping the head of a scarecrow. When edward shows bella what he looks like in the sunlight i didnt even notice he was sparkling for about 5 minutes and then i thought well anyone can do that but I pictured him almost glowing. The running was cheesy because all they did was made the actors run and then moved the background. Now I know they could have done much more with that. Alice,jasper,emmett, and Rosalie had about one line. In the book they werent really main characters but they talked alot more and i love alice and emmett but i hardly ever saw them in the movie. I bet they did all their acting in one day and they were done. Yet another thing i wanted to touch base on is edward went into bella's room once and talked at night. In the book i could have sworn that he went in every night for like a month. I thought that they did a poor job picking the actor to play jacob black. No offence jacob and taylor lovers but he really isnt how i pictured jacob. I always thought of jacob as tall and muscler but he was scrawny and well I dont have to say much more. When they are in the meadow...um... where to start, now I live in wisconsin and in the country so what i think of a meadow is a field with tall grass but really this was a clearing in the trees with a few mushrooms and frankly you didnt see hardly any of it. I don't know if watching New Moon will even be worth it when it comes out for one thing i hate jacob and well it wasnt my favorite book. Twilight has failed me and hopfully New Moon won't. Twilight Industry Reviews
 
* [http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/twilight/ rottentomatoes.com]
 
* [http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/twilight/ rottentomatoes.com]
 
* [http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/television/reviews/article_display.jsp?JSESSIONID=8QDsJlGhDV16TNXXL77SJTvGq1YpRxgGYwnqxwq8LjvBkzcHcqFx!1589509220&&rid=11981 hollwoodreporter.com] "An Underwhelming vampire romance long on camp but short on emotional insight"
 
* [http://www.hollywoodreporter.com/hr/television/reviews/article_display.jsp?JSESSIONID=8QDsJlGhDV16TNXXL77SJTvGq1YpRxgGYwnqxwq8LjvBkzcHcqFx!1589509220&&rid=11981 hollwoodreporter.com] "An Underwhelming vampire romance long on camp but short on emotional insight"

Revision as of 02:36, 25 November 2008


<-- back to Twilight

Fan Reviews

Add your review/comments on the movie here! Don't forget to sign your post with ~~~~


The movie was god-awful. The effects on the glitter were especially horrific. I cannot believe that people are actually enjoying the tripe. It completely ruined everything that made the book great, and the entire epic tale was covered in cheese and cardboard-cutout acting. The multiple inconsistencies and fridge logic (I’m going to SLAM your wall and make sure it is perfectly fine) are just plain *facepalm*-worthy. The big fight scene showcases one of the major ones I had a problem with (at one part Edward’s face was slammed into a glass mirror and he was bleeding, a couple of scenes later he was PERFECTLY FINE).

Plan Nine from Outer Space was better than this.

BellaOrwell 07:08, 24 November 2008 (UTC)




the movie was 1000 BETTER then i thought. Edward was soo cute ! && jasper . the directors did AWESOME with the movie. i loved the last scene with victoria was FANTASTIC!! they better make a 2 one. =) i love twilight!!!

Twilight_lover



As a Twilight fan, I was expecting a lot from this movie. I started the series on Saturday, Oct. 18th, 2008, and finished it four days later. I fell in love. So my friend came up with a brilliant idea to pre-order tickets for the movie for Nov. 21st. I was ALL FOR IT! But, then I got to the theater, and I was sadley dissapointed. Beyond belief. They changed every wonderful part in the book, to make it into...that. Don't get me wrong, I'll still watch it a thousand times over like Harry Potter, but it was not at my expectations. However, the people I was with thought it was "absolutly amazing" (they havn't finished the series), so I've come to the conclusion that everyone is different. I still LOVE Twilight, and I can't wait for New Moon!
(P.S., Emmett, Alice, Victoria and James were AMAZING. I love Robert Pattinson and Kristen Stewart.)

The last horcrux 01:21, 25 November 2008 (UTC)

I read the series over the summer and loved them. I am a guy which alot find strange but the way i see it is that gender doesnt matter what you read, and i am not gay which i have been teased about ready this book, anyways I loved the books and i obsessed over the movie all summer and I had posters and picture on msn and myspace but sadly I hated the movie. The effects stunk alot, at the end of the movie I seriously thought is that it? I think the fight scene was the only exciting part and then of course edward was bleeding and if i recall so wwas james. Now i thought vampires couldnt bleed. Another thing is when alice ripes jame's head off it looks like she's slapping the head of a scarecrow. When edward shows bella what he looks like in the sunlight i didnt even notice he was sparkling for about 5 minutes and then i thought well anyone can do that but I pictured him almost glowing. The running was cheesy because all they did was made the actors run and then moved the background. Now I know they could have done much more with that. Alice,jasper,emmett, and Rosalie had about one line. In the book they werent really main characters but they talked alot more and i love alice and emmett but i hardly ever saw them in the movie. I bet they did all their acting in one day and they were done. Yet another thing i wanted to touch base on is edward went into bella's room once and talked at night. In the book i could have sworn that he went in every night for like a month. I thought that they did a poor job picking the actor to play jacob black. No offence jacob and taylor lovers but he really isnt how i pictured jacob. I always thought of jacob as tall and muscler but he was scrawny and well I dont have to say much more. When they are in the meadow...um... where to start, now I live in wisconsin and in the country so what i think of a meadow is a field with tall grass but really this was a clearing in the trees with a few mushrooms and frankly you didnt see hardly any of it. I don't know if watching New Moon will even be worth it when it comes out for one thing i hate jacob and well it wasnt my favorite book. Twilight has failed me and hopfully New Moon won't. Twilight Industry Reviews

  • rottentomatoes.com
  • hollwoodreporter.com "An Underwhelming vampire romance long on camp but short on emotional insight"
  • MTV: " Twilight': Teen Anemia
  • Variety "a disappointingly anemic tale of forbidden love that should satiate the pre-converted"
  • EW.com "Hardwicke stirs this teen pulp to a pleasing simmer."
  • Starpulse.com "If you're coming into this material cold, though, you will be seriously baffled as to what the fuss is all about,"
  • The Village Voice "... the movie version gives really good swoon."
  • USA today "Neither strong sunlight nor the sight of oozing blood will deter the romance between a teenage girl and her vampire dreamboat in Twilight (* * out of four).And despite questionable casting, wooden acting, laughable dialogue and truly awful makeup, nothing is likely to stop young girls from swarming to this kitschy adaptation of Stephenie Meyer's popular novel.
  • Roger Ebert 2½ stars