Twilight Saga Wiki
Advertisement

The following are noted differences between the original novel and the segments.

Warning-icon Warning - this page contains numerous spoilers about both the novel and the film. Read on at your own risk!


Please Note: Changes are not in any particular order.

The Mary Alice Brandon File

Book Movie
Alice's parents were not named in the novels. Alice's parents are named Edgar John Brandon and Lillian Brandon. Her stepmother is named Anna-Marie Brandon.
Alice has a vision of her mother's killer coming after her and runs to her relatives' home before they turned her away, forcing her to find the town marshal. She went immediately to the town marshal.

Consumed

Book Movie
Jane and Alec's mother did not appear. Jane and Alec's mother did appear.

Sunrise

Book Movie
When the sun came up, Tia wanted to hide Benjamin, fearing the sun would kill him. This did not happen.

The Groundskeeper

Book Movie
Alice's creator kept James at bay until he was overpowered. Victoria tortured him to extract information in case there were other vampires. James and Victoria fought until he lost his stamina and fell. Victoria did not brutally interrogate him.

We've Met Before

Book Movie
Alice walks up to Jasper immediately when he walks in and holds out her hand for him to take. She waits until he is seated at a counter and Jasper is the one to hold out his hand.

Masque

Book Movie
There was no mention of anything that happened in this segment.

Turncoats

Book Movie
It was never revealed where and how Carlisle and Garrett met. In Breaking Dawn - Part 2, it was revealed that they met during the Battle at Yorktown.
Advertisement