Talk:Carlisle Cullen

From Twilight Saga Wiki

should'nt charliebe on the page

Please sign your posts, and why would Charlie be on this page? Carlisle is the guy who created the rest of the Olympic Coven, and Charlie is Bella's dad. They are barely related, and that's only by Edward and Bella's marriage.---Jasper- 03:54, 18 May 2009 (UTC)

bella needs connection with her father. it doesnt matter if he's mortal, everybody needs a father. :) and bella has carlisle as a father in law and charlie as her real father. <3

[edit] I LOVE YOU CARLISLE!

Why is it that almost everybody is obsessed with Edward Cullen? No offense, guys, but Carlisle is INFINITELY hotter!