Please note that the form this list is using is considered to be defunct.
to edit or add a reason to this top-ten list!
Jacob is a werewolf and Renesmee is a half Vampire.
Bella wouldn't hate him.
He is a tough dude, she is a softie
Leah! They could've been great together
It makes things WAY more complicated and pretty much turned the entire series into a soap opera.
He tells her mother that she is the love of his life.
Pretty lame that Jacob's love for Bella that he built up for a good two years would be replaced by her baby daughter in an instant like that.
I doubt that they could make any babies
Jacob has to wait seven years for anything to happen
Feel free to keep the list going!
Jacob would become Bella's son-in-law. AND HE MADE OUT WITH HER. HE WAS IN LOVE WITH HER.
It would have made a better plot device for him to have killed her.
Half-werewolf/half-vampire just won't work....
Jacob will deny Nessie the experience of "Finding your other half".
If Nessie rejects Jacob then Jacob will probably force her to be with him, forming a toxic and maybe even abusive relationship.
Jacob needs to get over Bella but being around her 24/7 doesn't help!!
Jacob was in love with Bella. Then she "died", so he deluded himself into thinking he imprinted on Renesmee.
Jacob will smell like a wet dog to Renesmee and she will stink according to Jacob after 7years so how can they even stand together.
Renesmee will always be disturbed by the fact that Jacob once was in love with her mother.
Pedophiliacs will rejoice
Jacob imprinting on Renesmee makes the story seem like another "babies make everything better" movie.
Because Jacob is a major character and Renesmee is like a filler character.
Jacob had no choice!!! All his free will is gone, replaced by the obsessive need to be whatever Renesmee wants him to be....that's not love...that's just having a freaking slave at your beck and call
Jacob imprinting on Renesmee was just a lazy 'cheat' way to make the Shapeshifters and the Cullens 'allies' with the "Can't hurt an imprint" law.
Jacob liked Bella first now he likes renesmee
RENESMEE WILL BE HEART BROKEN IF SHE KNOWS THAT JACOB LOVED BELLA
Jacob is too "old" for Renesmee
Werewoles and half-vampires right? So if they had children, then later those children would have children, and line goes on, with the top descenders.
If they had children, what would their abilities be?
Jacob? A husband? A father? Sickening.
renesme will stay young and Jacob will age.
CHILD GROOMING. Enough said.
The imprinting process essentially makes Jacob a willing slave, and Renesmee was already taking advantage of his servitude from day one.
Neither of them had any say in it. One is a child bride, and the other has no free will.
Jacob will end up dying one day while he's still with Renesmee
There is no 'forever' in their relationship and there will never be.
Falling in love with a newborn baby is just gross
Renesmee is a big MARY SUE like her mother Bella
This list uses a defunct format. Due to technical restrictions, lists using this format can not be converted to the current format.
However, lists using this format are still kept and may continue to be edited.
This list does not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Twilight Saga Wiki but rather the individual editors of the list.
Edit in regular format
See also: "
Ten Reasons Jacob Should Be With Renesmee"