Please note that the form this list is using is considered to be defunct.
to edit or add a reason to this top-ten list!
She doesn't deserve to be a vampire.
It seems like she loved Edward more as a human, and now her love is mostly directed at Renesmee
Everything was better as a human.
She doesn't deserve all of the happiness she received.
She shouldn't make Rosalie hate her even more.
Because she was not dying until she gave birth.
Edward never wanted her to change. Neither did Jacob. She should've made them both happy by staying a human.
She's the same as any other human.
She wouldn't have to say goodbye to her friends and her family.
She barely knew Edward when she decided to become one.
Feel free to keep the list going!
She should let Edward and Jacob have fun killing the vampires that try to kill her.
She don't need to drink blood as a human.
It would have given Jacob more time to fight for her.
She should still have a soul.
She doesn't deserve to spend eternity with Edward and his family.
She was better as a human, and she should have both Edward and Jacob.
Both Edward and Jacob didn't want her to be a blood sucking demon.
She knew that nobody wanted her to be a vampire, she was caring for herself.
Edward would be way better without her, I mean she is way to needy
This list uses a defunct format. Due to technical restrictions, lists using this format can not be converted to the current format.
However, lists using this format are still kept and may continue to be edited.
This list does not necessarily reflect the opinions of the Twilight Saga Wiki but rather the individual editors of the list.
Edit in regular format